A win is a win is a win is a win is a win is a win is a win is a win – Part II

halfpenny_2472029byoysoy concludes his examination of Wales’ win over France by casting his eye over the backs … and those coaches

Phillips – He makes poor decisions too often to be a reliable attacking or controlling scrum-half, but what he lacks in that area he more than makes up for with his physical presence. A couple of powerful runs, his usual muscular self as a defender (tearing back to stop and strip the ball off Picamoles being the highlight). Some good kicks, some bad ones. He was well up for it on the weekend. I suppose his performance is a microcosm of the Welsh one: flawed, powerful, dogged.

danbiggarBiggar – He’s not taking an axe to the door of Lions selections, but he is showing signs of growing into the team. His line kicking was top drawer putting his forwards 40 metres downfield each time. His kicking game, overall, was patchier: a couple out on the full; up-and-unders generally a bit too far; one weird one off the outside of his boot; but interspersed with some good kicks. The little dink for North’s try was beautifully weighted. Still some question marks about his defence, if not his commitment. Once he begins to get more comfortable with his surroundings, we should see him begin to be his more vocal Osprey self. Got a nice hug of his Mam after the match, too.

North – Jizzbucket, God, Overrated, English… call him what you want but he’s a very good player for a 20 year-old. Saw little ball but an average of 6 metres gained per touch tells us that he makes and breaks the gainline more often than not. By no means the finished article, he still struggles with kicks in behind (there was only the one in this match) and his timing at hitting a line is variable, but his strengths largely outweigh his weaknesses. The try was superbly taken. There was no room for error with such little space to work in. Terrific athletic and footballing ability to score.


Roberts – Solid defensive channel, the glue of every good defensive effort. There were even some tentative signs that Wales may be trying to use him a little differently. On three occasions he was used as a link and North as the inside runner off him. The timing was off on two of them but there has always been more to his game than running very hard in a straight line. Cried on Welsh TV, too.

Davies – See Roberts. You don’t become a bad player overnight. Kept his passes simple, even putting Halfpenny through a gap off his (shriek!) left hand. Sound as he usually is in defence. Unfussy performance. Good to see.

Cuthbert – No real defensive howlers this week. Not really a game for wingers to show their wares but he manned up and made some hard yards when required. He’s played almost as many test matches as he has games for his region and the international stage is an unforgiving place to be doing most of your learning. All in all, a fair effort.

Halfpenny – One charged-down kick aside, pretty flawless. Mr Reliably High Standards.

Replacements – Owens made a couple of decent carries, James made no difference to the scrum and Lloyd Williams looked lively in his short cameo. Others had no time to impress.


Coaches – Howley can justifiably say he got his selection right (even if Ryan Jones was originally slated for the bench before Warburton’s injury) and deserves a little bit of breathing space after mustering up the first win in 9 matches.

Defensively, I imagine Edwards beasted them all week. France attacked with such a lack of variety and precision that it’s hard to estimate how much better Wales were in this department compared to the debacle of the Irish match. These fellas are off the hook for now, but we need to see a continuous improvement over the rest of the tournament.

Welsh fans will now be expecting the moon on a stick, probably. They’ll settle for a win in the next game. And if we win that, we’ll expect another. Et cetera. You’ve got to dog it out sometimes, and for all the justified stick they took during the losing streak, they deserve some kudos for winning this one late on.

This entry was posted in Six Nations 2013 and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

1,026 Responses to A win is a win is a win is a win is a win is a win is a win is a win – Part II

  1. PlanetoftheChimps says:


    Too much overdogging of Scotland based on 1 home win against Italy & a gubbing by England in my opinion

    Even with Ronads / father time / colostomy ron at 10 (I still have nightmares about him handing off Ross Ford for a try a couple of years ago) they’re a quality team.

    With a settled squad & established coaching regime

  2. Karl1976 says:

    I like the fact that The Terminator didn’t have a huge budget – it kept it really ‘dark’, particularly with the soundtrack sounding like it was done on someone’s DX7 at home rather than in a studio. T2 also has a great storyline, but is far more polished.

    It’d take someone who knows more about such things than me, but I’m not sure the CGI technology existed in 1983 to have made something like T2, where the T1000’s body morphs into liquid metal and other people and objects. It was probably cutting edge in 1990. I tend not to like modern action movies because often ‘doing it cheap’ these days means using CGI to do a vehicle crash. They still haven’t got them right…

  3. Duncan S says:

    POTC – you forgot Old Man River.

  4. Piperboy says:

    I think Kilcoyne will do just fine in Healy’s place. He may not be the turnover monster but his carrying is really good and he’ll do ok in the set-piece (is it a Sunday game?)

    No underdogging from me. If it’s dry Ireland win. If it’s wet then who the fuck knows. I’m just hoping there’s a taser involved in basic skills training this week.

  5. flaviafamkesandwich says:

    Ned Flanders: Don’t worry, kids. I am not going to shoot your father.
    Homer Simpson: Flanders? Shoot me?
    Homer Simpson: You’ve never killed anyone and now you’re gonna start with the big dog?
    Ned Flanders: Homer, don’t tempt the gods, er, I mean God. There’s one God; only one. Well, sometimes there’s three.

Comments are closed.